Sandia Lab News
April 25,1997 

Comet crash: Teraflops computer simulates colossal comet impact into ocean

Sandia excercise a tuneup for world's fastest computer

Ken Frazier

(back to Lab News contents page)

Even before it's at full strength, the new teraflops (trillion operations per second) supercomputer at Sandia is making a big splash worldwide. During the initial testing of the new computer, Gil Weigand, DOE Deputy Assistant Secretary for Strategic Computing and Simulation, requested that Sandia complete a simulation that would be of general interest to the scientific community. For this reason, and also to generate unclassified data to test innovative visualization techniques, Sandia scientist David Crawford (9232) has carried out a computational simulation of a major cosmic event of potential significance to all people on Earth: What would happen if a kilometer-wide comet struck the ocean?Color images and animation are available at this Web site: http://www.sandia.gov/1431/COMETw.html


COMET CRASH - Sandia supercomputer simulations of a one-kilometer comet entering Earth's atmosphere, approaching the ocean's surface, and impacting the ocean, deforming the ocean floor and creating a giant high-pressure steam explosion rising into the stratosphere. The explosion ejects comet vapor and water vapor into ballistic trajectories that spread around the globe. The New York City skyline is shown for scale. (Click on image for page containing larger view) 
Even before it's at full strength, the new teraflops (trillion operations per second) supercomputer at Sandia is making a big splash worldwide. During the initial testing of the new computer, Gil Weigand, DOE Deputy Assistant Secretary for Strategic Computing and Simulation, requested that Sandia complete a simulation that would be of general interest to the scientific community. For this reason, and also to generate unclassified data to test innovative visualization techniques, Sandia scientist David Crawford (9232) has carried out a computational simulation of a major cosmic event of potential significance to all people on Earth: What would happen if a kilometer-wide comet struck the ocean?

A kilometer is about the size of the largest fragment of Comet Shoemaker-Levy 9 that crashed into Jupiter in 1994 - an event that was also the subject of highly praised computational simulations by Dave and colleague Mark Boslough (also 9232). The close correspondence between those predictions of a visible plume rising above the rim of Jupiter and the actual plume as observed by astronomers lent even more confidence to the accuracy of the Sandia simulation codes.

The new calculation again used Sandia's famous CTH "bang and splat" shock physics code, but this time the simulation was run on 1,500 processors of the new Intel Teraflops computer being installed in Bldg. 880. That's only one-sixth of the expected final 9,000-processor configuration.

The calculation assumed a 1-kilometer-diameter comet (weighing about a billion tons) traveling 60 kilometers per second and impacting Earth's atmosphere at about a 45š angle. This is small as far as comets go (the massive Comet Hale-Bopp weighs about ten trillion tons).

The problem was divided into 54 million zones and ran for 48 hours. The results, although dramatic, pretty much confirm earlier predictions about a comet impact, but they do so with much finer resolution in three dimensions than has ever before been possible.

A revolution in science

"What's unique about this is we can now do three-dimensional simulations on the Intel teraflops computer that can fully resolve all the physics of the impact," Dave says. The fully-resolved three-dimensional resolution is extraordinary.

"It's like an astronomer getting a new, more powerful telescope," says Mark. "I think it's a major step forward in science." He said the capability raises computational simulations to the status of a third branch of scientific inquiry equal to, and complementary to, experimentation and theorizing.

"It really is a revolution in science," Mark says. "A lot of major breakthroughs in science are going to come from these kinds of supercomputers." He notes that the comet-impact simulation is something that can't be done any other way. "It's almost like doing an experiment - one you could never do. One you would never want to do."

Dave and Mark spoke at a news conference called quickly last week after a local newspaper report about the work was distributed nationally by the Associated Press.

300-gigaton impact

The news about the comet-impact simulation even led commentator Paul Harvey's nationally syndicated radio show that morning. News media in Florida were especially interested - the news reports noted that the tremendous splash from an impact in the Atlantic Ocean would, among other things, completely overrun Florida.

But that was just a short-term effect.

Here's what the new Sandia simulations show (see illustrations below).

The simulation starts with the comet 30 kilometers above the surface. The comet produces a strong luminescent bow shock in the atmosphere as it speeds downwards. Seven-tenths of a second later it hits the ocean with an impact energy of 300 gigatons of TNT - about 10 times the explosive power of all the nuclear weapons in existence in the 1960s at the height of the Cold War - forming a large transient cavity in the ocean and a dent in the ocean floor. The comet itself is almost instantaneously vaporized, along with 300 to 500 cubic kilometers of ocean. This high-pressure steam explosion rises into the atmosphere. Comet vapor and water vapor are ejected into ballistic trajectories that will take it around the globe, with some of it even achieving escape velocity.

Low-lying areas like Florida would indeed be washed over, but Dave says the event is very close to the size threshold at which impact experts expect that a global catastrophe could occur, by screening out much sunlight for long periods of time and disrupting agriculture, among other effects. "Simulations of this kind can help pin down that energy threshold and help answer the question: Is it a regional or global catastrophe?"

Low-probability, high consequence

What is the likelihood of something like this happening?

Mark says the estimated probability is that an asteroid or comet with this energy strikes Earth about once every 300,000 years. Another way of looking at it is that there is about a 1 in 3,000 chance of its happening in a given century. "It's a low-probability, high-consequence event," he says. "But if it did hit, the probability of your becoming a victim would be high."

Sandia's teraflops computer is a joint development of DOE, Sandia, and Intel. It represents the initial goal of DOE's Accelerated Strategic Computing Initiative (ASCI), a ten-year program designed to move nuclear weapons design and maintenance from a test-based to simulation-based approach. DOE announced last December, when the machine was then still at Intel, that the one-trillion-operations-per-second breakthrough had been achieved.

The full machine is expected to have a peak performance capability of 1.8 teraflops, or 1.8 trillion mathematical operations per second. DOE and the weapons labs are developing continually more powerful supercomputers to simulate the complex 3-D physics involved in nuclear-weapon performance and to accurately predict the degradation of nuclear weapon components as they age in the stockpile.

The comet-simulation was essentially a test of the teraflops machine's capabilities. "This is an exercise for the computer," says Mark (who notes that he's also using it for a weapon-component simulation), "but we wanted to do something that people would be interested in."

Color images and animation are available at this Web site: http://www.sandia.gov/1431/ COMETw.html 


back to beginning of article
back to Lab News contents page

If you have questions or need further information, contact Rod Geer by e-mail at: wrgeer@sandia.gov
Last Modified: April 28, 1997